But, The Lease Guaranty Had All Of The Right Words – What Happened?

Print

“I guarantee the full performance of the Lease by the Tenant. This Guarantee is absolute and without any conditions. … This guarantee will not be affected by any change in the Lease whatsoever, including, but not limited to any extension of time or renewals.” “The Guarantor further agrees that this guaranty shall remain and continue in full force and effect as to any renewal, change or extension of the Lease.”

Those were two ways in which two different landlord’s forms of guaranty were intended to give the landlord comfort that a guarantor would not weasel out of the guarantee based upon amendments, extensions, etc. to the guaranteed lease. They didn’t work.

What went wrong? Basically, including such language in a guarantee helps make the guarantee bullet-resistant, not bullet-proof. [Read more…]

Print

What Kind Of Help To A Tenant Is Self-Help? Part 2

Print

Last week, we opened the topic of tenant self-help rights. We’re not going to do much repetition. So, if you haven’t seen it yet or, if you are like us, you’ve forgotten most of what you’ve read, click HERE to see that posting.

In that posting, we gave some examples of when a tenant with the right to do what its landlord should have done, won’t. In short, a tenant occupying one percent of a property isn’t very likely to plow an entire parking lot or replace a lot of roof area. That caveat doesn’t make the tenant’s self-help right entirely useless. Not all tasks are so extensive or expensive. Here are easy examples: a manageable roof leak or a rooftop HVAC replacement (in each case, assuming the landlord had responsibility to take care of those items). [Read more…]

Print

Do I Have To Pay Operating Expense Charges Or Taxes That My Landlord Just Billed Me For After Five Years?

Print

We’ve pondered, actually struggled, to post a piece exploring the answer to the often asked, “Do I have to pay operating expense charges or taxes that my landlord just billed me for after five years?” What we’ve found is that there is no simple answer if the lease in question doesn’t specifically cover delayed billings like this. That’s also true for related questions such as, “We never increased our rent payment after extending its term and now, five years later, our landlord wants all the back rent – do we have to pay?” Or, to, “We’ve been paying the wrong rent, can we get our money back? [Read more…]

Print

Landlords Rejoice – Your Tenant Is Borrowing Money

Print

Everyone accepts that property owners borrow money for their businesses. Very few properties are unencumbered by a mortgage. Other than in a very, very limited number of situations, tenants readily, perhaps automatically, accept that their lease will be subordinate to at least the lien of a mortgage. If a tenant can be insulated from the bad effects of a lender taking over a property or from the fallout of a foreclosure, it will or should be somewhat indifferent to having a lender or a new owner step in when its then-landlord can’t financially support the property any longer. Yes, it is messy, but think [Read more…]

Print

You Can Get Badly Hurt When The Boilerplate Falls On You – A Lease’s Boilerplate Clause Deconstructed Today

Print

Small spaces leased by small landlords to small tenants are often handled with small leases. In many cases, a “small” lease means a “standard” (read that: purchased) lease form. Even where this is not the case, the provisions in many leases sprung out of such “standard” forms. That’s especially true when it comes to their “boilerplate.” [Boilerplate – thought to originate from certain type of printing plates that were intended to be permanent and unchangeable, such as for an advertisement to be printed in a newspaper “as-is.” They were on heavy metal plates that resembled the riveted metal plates that would house a boiler.] [Read more…]

Print

How Should A Landlord Respond To A Lender’s Request For A Consent And Lien Waiver; Should A Tenant Care?

Print

Landlord’s lien waivers deal with more than just the pure statement that a landlord waives its lien rights to, (or subordinates its lien rights against), the rights of a lender or of an equipment lessor. Certainly, those parties have a legitimate concern about the integrity of their collateral and their ability to sell the goods and equipment in place or to remove the collateral for sale elsewhere. For that reason, landlord lien waivers include, among other terms, provisions defining the personal property covered, waiving and subordinating liens, providing for storage or holdover, and dealing with removal. [Read more…]

Print

For What Would A Landlord Want To Be Indemnified?

Print

Our last posting brought out dozens of comments, representing a wide spectrum of views. Almost all responders noted the connection between letters of intent and the time it takes to get a deal done. Beyond that there was little consensus. So, we’ve had over 100 comments on that topic – getting the deal done faster – but no one yet has suggested a major reason. Ruminations has a suggestion – the people responsible for negotiating leases (especially) don’t seem to have a sense of urgency. [Read more…]

Print

Waivers of Subrogation – Part 2 (It’s Free and Easy)

Print

Last time, I tried to lay out my understanding about “What is a Waiver of Subrogation Waiver Anyway?” When I concluded that rant, I promised to explain why I think it is easy to have such a Waiver of Subrogation provision in a property insurance policy and that it is “free” and you don’t even have to ask for it. If I am right about that, then the release of claims provisions and the Waiver of Subrogation provision should be relegated to the status of “boilerplate” or nearly so. [Read more…]

Print